Wine Spectator 90 points - Massive, with firm tannins and fine structure, this
tightly wound young wine will need time to show
its stuff, as it’s dense and concentrated, offering only
glimpses of what lies ahead. Dried currant, herb, sage
and wild berry flavors, with chewy tannins on the
finish. Those patient enough to cellar it may be in for
a pleasant surprise. Best from 2008 through 2014.—J.L. (May 18 2005)
Robert Parker 96 points - When all of these cuvees are blended together, the result is the finest Cabernet Sauvignon yet made by Ed Sbragia, the 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon Private Reserve (11,000 cases of truly divine Cabernet nectar). For statisticians, 44% came from the Steinhauer Vineyard, 1% from Bancroft Ranch, 17% from Rancho del Oso, 3% from Chabot, 13% from St. Helena Home Ranch, 0% from Quarry Vineyard, and the balance from Marston Vineyard. As I reported last year, the 2001 is an extraordinary effort. Large-scaled yet elegant, it boasts classic notes of creme de cassis, chocolate, and smoky oak. With extraordinary voluptuousness, great concentration, tremendous intensity, and a finish that lasts nearly 60 seconds, this saturated purple-colored, full-bodied Cabernet Sauvignon is one of the greatest wines ever made at Beringer. It is a tribute to the brilliant Ed Sbragia. Anticipated maturity: 2007-2023.
(Feb 2005)